Activity 1: Customers Cut the Cake
Each day the local baker makes several rectangular sheet cakes, which he cuts into eighths. He sells 1/8 of a sheet cake for $1.59. As part of a new promotional campaign for his store, he wants to cut his sheet cakes into eighths a
different way each day. Customers who suggest a new way to cut the cakes into eighths win a free piece of cake each day for a week. What are some of the different ways to
cut the cake?
Some questions to ask students include:
- What is the shape of the baker's cakes? (Rectangular cakes)
- What are the restrictions on the ways the cakes can be cut? (Pieces must contain the same amount of cake; they do not have to be the same shape.)
- How can we verify that pieces that are not the same shape contain the same amount of cake? (Cut the pieces into smaller parts and lay one on top of the other.)
This activity gives students opportunities to represent parts of a whole by using an area model of fractions. Many students know that fractions often refer to equal-sized parts of a unit, but they frequently overgeneralize and believe that the pieces have to be congruent rather than merely contain the same area.
Encourage students to solve the problem in pairs or in small groups by using the Cakes Cut Into Eighths activity sheet.
Alternatively, students can use rectangular pieces of paper to model the cakes, sketching the shapes or cutting the paper into eight
pieces and verifying the equivalence of the pieces by cutting and overlapping. Some students may have a limited view and think that all the cuts must be parallel to
one side of the rectangle. Challenge them to think of other ways to make the cuts. (It is important for students to know that each rectangle on the activity sheet represents a full cake.)
Have students place their designs on the chalkboard or the overhead projector. Ask the students to decide which designs are the same and which are different. Examples of some diagrams are shown below. Have the students discuss whether the two rectangles in this figure are cut differently.
What factors should be considered when deciding whether the two designs are different? (The number of pieces, the equivalence of the pieces, and whether the location of the pieces makes a difference should be considered.) The two
rectangles in the above figure contain the same eight pieces, but the pieces are arranged differently. The students can decide whether they want to consider these as two different arrangements.
Another way that must be considered is using cuts that are curves or combinations of line segments, such as the examples in the figure below.
The equivalence of shapes formed by cuts that are curves is
difficult to determine but is a good investigation in itself. The equivalence of shapes that are formed by cuts that are combinations of straight line segments is easier to determine. Including these types of shapes, however,
again greatly increases the number of possibilities. By interacting with students, decide which designs to include in the final count.
Ask each group to choose one design and either to post it on the chalkboard or bulletin board or to draw it on the overhead projector. Students in each group should be prepared to explain how they know that their method shows
eighths. One way to verify that a solution does in fact result in eighths is to cut up the individual pieces further and lay them on top of each other to verify the equivalence of their areas.
As a follow-up activity,
teachers may choose to discuss with students why or why not each cake on below is cut into eighths.
Activity 2: You Can Eat Your Cake and Have It, Too!
The baker is conducting a second contest, this time for his employees. As part of a new promotional campaign for his store, each day he wants to feature sheet cakes that have been cut into four pieces in a different way. The pieces do not have to be equal for this promotion. The baker has challenged his employees to suggest interesting ways to cut the cakes into four pieces. The employees must also determine the price for each piece. The bakery sells 1/8 of a sheet cake for $1.59. What are some of the different ways the cakes can be cut, and how much should each piece cost?
Some questions for the students to discuss include:
- What are the restrictions on the ways the cakes are cut? (Each cake must be cut into four pieces, not necessarily equal-sized pieces.)
- How can we determine the fractional parts of the pieces we cut? (We can use equivalences we know, such as 2/4 is equivalent to 1/2, to find the value of each part, if we partition by finding parts of parts.)
- What will happen if we just cut four pieces at random? (It will be difficult to determine the size of each piece.)
Instead of focusing on making equal-sized pieces as in the previous activity, this activity explores determining the fractional parts and cost of pieces when a unit is cut into four unequal parts.
Encourage students to solve the problem in pairs or small groups by using the Cakes Cut Into Fourths activity sheet or rectangular paper to model the cakes. They sketch the pieces or cut the rectangles into four pieces and determine the value of each piece.
One way to find the value of each piece is to add partitioning lines so that the whole is partitioned into equal-sized pieces. Students may remember some of the ways they cut the cakes into eighths in the first activity, which may help them. Once again, weighing could solve this problem.
The following overhead can be projected after students have had time to create their designs.
Have students share and discuss their designs. The rectangles shown below show a few possible ways to cut the rectangular cakes into four parts. The pieces have been labeled to show the fraction of the cake they represent.
Students must then find the cost for each piece, if 1/8 of a cake costs $1.59. What should the total cost of one whole cake be? (If 1/8 of a cake costs $1.59, then a whole cake should cost eight times as much, or $12.72.)
Challenge students to explain and verify their solutions.
Activity 3: That's the Way the Cookie Crumbles!
You bought a baker's dozen (13) of cookies that you want to share equally with your family. How many cookies will each person get?
Ask students to compare this problem with the one posed in the first activity. Give them time to think about the similarities and differences between this problem and the problem posed in Activity 1.
This problem is similar to the first problem, that of cutting rectangular sheet cakes into eighths in different ways, because they both involve partitioning a unit into parts. This problem is different in several ways: The whole or unit in this group of thirteen cookies; the problem does not specify exactly into how many pieces to cut each cookie or how many people are sharing the cookies; the problem has different solutions for students who have different-sized families; and this problem involves a different interpretation of rational numbers - the quotient interpretation. The quotient interpretation refers to the fact that in this problem, in which thirteen cookies are being shared by n people (n is the number of people in the family), the number of cookies each person receives is the quotient, 13÷n.
Consider grouping students according to the number of people in their families. Students can draw 13 circles on a piece of paper to practice dividing the cookies. After each group has solved the problem, share the solution processes with the whole class. Have each student complete a table similar to the sample
below.
The table should include all the different-sized families of students in the class and also contain a few other family sizes, including one or two families that are larger than the largest family in the class. Students should begin completing the table by including solutions from the groups in the class and then working on solving the problems for other family sizes.
Discuss the solutions, focusing on the patterns students see in the number of cookies for each person as the size of the family changes. The goal for students is to generalize that the number of cookies for each person is equal to the
number of cookies divided by the number of people sharing them.
Ask students to write a rule that represents the number of cookies each person receives if thirteen cookies are shared by n people (n is the number of people in one's family).
Solution: The number of cookies each person receives is the quotient, 13÷n.
Ask students to describe the way they solved the problem in their groups (e.g., by drawing a picture, using long division, and so on) so that a student in another class would understand what problem was solved and how it was solved.
