Thank you for your interest in NCTM’s Illuminations. Beginning in mid-April, all Illuminations content will be moving to nctm.org/illuminations. Interactives will remain openly available and NCTM members will have access to all Illuminations lessons with new filtering and search options. We hope you will continue to utilize and enjoy these resources on nctm.org.

## Rates and Taxes

• Lesson
9-12
2

This activity allows students to become familiar with percents and taxes. Students learn how to determine the amount of tax a family will pay based on a certain income. This lesson was adapted from an article by Warren W. Esty, which appeared in the May 1992 edition of Mathematics Teacher.

Benjamin Franklin said, "Nothing is certain but death and taxes." A mathematics class may not be the right place to discuss death, but it is a good place to discuss taxes. In the process, students can learn some important lessons about slopes, split functions, averages, rates, marginal rates, and percents (and taxes).

Taxes are an important political issue. Just prior to the 1990 elections, the federal deficit was very high, and taxes needed to be raised in spite of George Bush's 1988 campaign pledge, "Read my lips-no new taxes." Communicating to the people that any changes would be fair was important in that election. But most people did not understand the tax system in place, so they were in no position to understand the fairness of any changes.

The media did not help much. The terminology of tax rates and tax brackets was (and is) often incorrectly used in the newspapers and on television. As teachers, we can use terms properly to clarify what is really meant. Then, our students will be able to see how the tax brackets really work. This lesson presents the situation as it was for 1990 taxes due in April 1991. A source of further exercises can be done with any revisions in the tax laws, each of which is interesting, realistic, important, long, and manageable by algebra students.

Begin class by displaying Table 1 on the Rates and Taxes: Tables Overhead, and ask, "What does a family with an income of $40,000 pay in U.S. income taxes?" On the basis of the information in Table 1, students usually respond, "twenty-eight percent of forty thousand dollars." We will see that this answer is intuitive but wrong, and consequently, the public is easily misled by tax rate arguments. ### The Real-World Solution To correct this misconception, generalize your original question to, "How much would a family of four with an income of x dollars pay in taxes? What is the tax rate?" To answer these questions, introduce some technical tax terms (that appear on Form 1040, which serves as a good prop). Two technical terms for income need explanation. Adjusted gross income (AG income) is similar to what we normally think of as income. But taxpayers are entitled to some deductions from their AG income before computing their tax. Only taxable income is taxed. To find taxable income, a family could take from their AG income a standard deduction of$5,450 plus an additional $2,050 deduction for each person in the family. For ease of comparison, use the example of a family of four, hereinafter referred to as "a family." Their taxable income is their AG income minus deductions:$5,450 + 4($2,050) =$13,650

Some families are entitled to even more deductions, but tell students that the complexity of the U.S. tax code prevents you from discussing them here. To make sure that students understand taxable income, ask probing questions, such as:

• Why does a family with an income of $10,000 pay no federal income tax? [Because they have no taxable income. In other words, the deduction is greater than their income. Tell students that because there is no taxable income,$10,000 is considered to be nontaxable income.]
• What is the taxable income of a family with an income of $20,000? [Their taxable income is$20,000 - $13,650 =$6,350.]
• Up to what amount would be considered nontaxable income?
[$13,650. After your taxable income exceeds this amount, you will begin to have taxable income.] Now, come back to the original question asked at the beginning of the class: "What does a family with an income of$40,000 pay in U.S. income taxes?"

Students should now be able to say that a family with $40,000 of regular income will be in the 15 percent bracket, not the 28 percent bracket, since$40,000-$13,650=$26,350.

Tell students that you will denote AG income by x and taxes by T(x). Let y denote taxable income. You may wish to write this on the board so that students can refer to it during the lesson.

Ask students to create a general equation for the taxable income of a family. [y = x - 13,650.]

With this notation, tell students that they can interpret the first line of Table 1 algebraically as:

T = 0.15y, for 0 < y < 32,450

Ask students to convert this formula to a function of x (which is AG income):

T(x) = 0.15(x - 13,650) = 0.15x - 2,047.50, for 0 < x-13,650 ≤ 32,450 or 13,650 < x ≤ 46,100

In order to ensure that students understand the function, ask probing questions, such as:
• "How much AG income can you earn and still be in the 15 percent tax bracket?"
[$46,100.] • "How much does a family that earns$10,000 (AG income) pay in taxes?"
[$0.] • "How about a family that earns$20,000?"
[T(20,000)=0.15(20,000)-2,047.5=$952.50.] Now ask students, "What, then, is the tax rate?" By definition, a rate is a quantity of something measured for each unit of something else. That is, a quotient of quantities. Now, ask students to find the tax rate of the family that earned an AG income of$10,000 and $20,000. [0% and , respectively.] Ask students to note that this is certainly not a 15% rate that was shown in Table 1! Now display Figure 1in the Rates and Taxes: Graphs Overhead. Before continuing, define marginal tax rate to students as the percentage of tax applied to your income based off of your earnings. Ask students to discuss, in a think-pair-share manner, what the graph is depicting. You may also wish to have students write down their thoughts as a form of assessment. In general, here is what the graph is portraying: Too many people think that the rates in the tax rate schedules refer to the actual tax rate (total taxes divided by total income). This notion is incorrect. The tax-bracket percents are actually marginal rates, not average rates. In the 15 percent bracket, "15 percent" refers to the slope of the tax line(s2). The average rate is the actual rate the taxpayer pays, that is, total tax divided by total income. That is the slope of the line segment (s1) through the origin and (x,T(x)), which is less than 15 percent (see the dashed line in Figure 1). The slope of the dashed line is the geometric representation of the average rate at (x, T(x)). Slopes alone do not determine heights. The intercept is important. With a marginal rate of 15 percent, each additional$100 of taxable income raises taxes by $15. Note that not every$100 of income is taxed $15. Figure 1 makes clear why the marginal rate is higher than the actual rate. After students understand this concept, derive a formula to determine the actual tax rate (for the 15 percent bracket) as a class. Let R(x) denote the actual tax rate. for 13,650 < ≤ 46,100. Ask students to find how much the actual tax rate varies. [By substitution 13,650 and 46,100, students should be able to determine that the rate varies from 0% to ≈10.56% for the 15 percent bracket]. It is never close to the nominal (marginal) rate of 15 percent! Now move up a bracket and interpret the second line of Table 1 with your students. Ask students how much a family with$50,000 of taxable income will be taxed. Some students may hold the misconception that all $50,000 will be taxed in the 28 percent tax bracket. But this is not true. A family with an income of$32,450–$78,400 pays 15 percent tax on a taxable income of$32,450 (the top of the lower bracket) and additional tax at a 28 percent marginal rate on taxable income above that level.

The taxes on $32,450 are$4,867.50.  Thus,

T = 4,867.50 + 0.28 (y-32,450), for 32,450 < ≤ 78,400

Changing to x, or AG income, we get:

T(x) = 4,867.50 + 0.28((x-13,650)-32,450), for 32,450 < x-13,650 ≤ 78,400, or

T(x)= 0.28x - 8,040.50, for 46,100 < x ≤ 92,050

A graph (extending Figure 1) of the tax split function over this wider interval is easy to create. In this bracket, the tax carried over from the previous bracket is $4,867.50 and the maximum tax is$17,733.50.

, for 46,100 < x ≤ 92,050

The marginal rate is 28 percent, but the actual rate varies from 10.56% through 19.27% (see Figure 2). Higher-income families not only pay higher taxes, they pay at a higher rate. And no family in this bracket pays close to 28 percent of income in taxes.

Now is a good time to discuss the so-called bubble. Most people do not understand the bubble, that is, the 33 percent bracket. This misunderstanding caused major political problems.  Taxpayers are concerned that the wealthiest people are not paying their fair share, and the bubble appeared to be a clear example.  People thought that those families with the highest incomes (y > $162,770) paid taxes at a lower rate (28%) than those with lower incomes in the bubble bracket (33%). This discrepancy seemed to them unfair and wrong. Have the class do the mathematics and then decide whether the tax discrepancy is unfair. Most students understand Table 1 by this point in the lesson. Again, the taxes of families in any bracket are calculated by computing the taxes owed by a family at the top end of the next-lower bracket plus a fixed percent of the income exceeding the bottom end of the bracket. Here are the calculations from the bubble bracket. T = 17,733.50 + 0.33(y - 78, 400), for 78,400 < y ≤ 162,770. T(x) = 17,733.50 + 0.33(x - 92,050) = 0.33x - 12, 643, for 92,050 <≤ 176,420. , for 92,050 < ≤ 176,420. ### Tax Deductions Decrease Taxable Income The tax carried over from the previous bracket to the bubble bracket is$17,733.50, and the maximum tax is $45,575.60. The actual rate varies from 19.27% to the maximum rate of 25.83%. The actual rate is never near 33 percent. More to the point, it is never near the 28 percent marginal rate in the next higher bracket. Taxpayers in the top bracket pay 25.83% on the first$176,420 of AG income and 28 percent on the rest.  (Actually, personal deductions are phased out as income increases in this bracket, so the truth is slightly more complex. See Schedule Y1 of Form 1040).  If their income is extremely high, their actual rate is close to 28 percent. In fact, in terms of y, the taxable income, the rate is a constant 28 percent; that is,

T = 45,575.60 + 0.28(y-162,770)

= 45,575.60 + 0.28y-45,575.60

= 0.28y

for y≤162,770. In the highest bracket, and only there, the actual rate really is the nominal (marginal) rate.  Without some sort of higher bubble-bracket rate, obtaining a constant rate for all families in the top bracket is not possible.  Note that the people in the bubble did not pay taxes at a higher actual rate than those in the highest bracket; they paid only a higher marginal rate.

Table 2 summarizes the tax brackets, taxes, and actual tax rates.

### Tax-Code Revisions

Students can learn a great deal about rates and taxes if they do the mathematics of possible tax revisions for themselves. For example, the primary change passed into law in 1990 as stated in the press was that the bubble bracket was eliminated and that the rates in that bracket and the highest bracket were both changed to 31 percent. This statement brings up some interesting questions. Disregarding all the other changes, how does this change in marginal rates affect taxes? Who will pay more in taxes than before? Who will pay less? Answer: If x < $92,050, taxpayers pay the same. If$92,050 < x < $232,666.67, they pay less. Only if x >$232,666.67 do they pay more.) Did the voting public understand this change?

Other problems concern the effect of changing deductions. For example, the tax brackets were the same in 1989, but the standard deduction was lower ($5,200) and personal deductions were lower ($2,000 per person). Was the change especially good for low-income families? Who benefits, and who benefits most, when the standard deduction is increased? (Answer: All taxpayers pay less, but the decrease is larger for families in higher brackets.) Did the voting public understand the ramifications? By the way, these results illustrate one reason that some people advocate tax credits rather than deductions. Tax credits decrease taxes, whereas tax deductions decrease taxable income.

Many interesting extensions can be developed. Refer to the Extensions section for recommendations.

### Summary

Semantic confusion has clouded understanding of important tax issues. The mathematical concepts of actual rates and marginal rates help explain the reality behind the political arguments. Of course, in this context marginal rates are simply slopes of lines and actual rates are slopes of lines through the origin. Slope is a fundamental concept of both algebra and calculus. Therefore, these vivid lessons about actual rates and marginal rates are appropriate for algebra and calculus students alike.

This tax lesson is a real-world application of mathematics that really catches my students' attention. Few or none of them appear to know how tax brackets work when I start.  At the end of the lesson, I get many comments about how pleased they are with their new knowledge. Most often I hear, "I never knew that's how taxes worked." I am asked how I think taxes ought to be changed, but I stay out of politics and never tell. My students don't seem to have any trouble with the mathematics after I explain Table 1. After all, most of the mathematics is just straight lines.

We tell our students that mathematics applies to real-world problems, but they do not often see really good applications. This significant problem can be done step by step using middle-level algebra skills. Not only does it explain taxes, thus serving also as a good civics lesson, but it also illuminates important concepts of mathematics.

### Reference

Warren W. Esty. Mathematics Teacher. May, 1992.

Assessment Options

1. Ask students to write down their answers to questions that are asked in class. Gather this as a form of assessment.
2. Perform informal assessments during peer to peer or in-class discussions. Take note of which students are able to comfortably answer questions and explain concepts of tax brackets.

Extensions

1. Explain the difference between actual tax rate and marginal tax rate.
2. Graph the income-to-tax function.  Graph the actual tax rate (see Figure 2).
3. Answer the following questions, which were in the news in 1990:
(a) Why was the bubble created?

(b) Why should the highest earners pay a smaller percent than those in the bubble bracket? (Answer: They don't.)

(c) Why are tax rates flat over such wide brackets? (Answer: They aren't.)

(d) Why should a poor family with $8,000 income pay the same percent as the relatively well-to-do family with$30,000 income? (Answer: They don't.)

4. For the top bracket, calculate the following:
(a) T(x)
(b) R(x)
(c) The top rate in terms of x
5. Suppose that lawmakers decide to keep the 33 percent bracket and increase the top bracket's marginal rate to 31 percent. How should the upper end of the 33 percent bracket be changed so that the top rate is a constant 31 percent in terms of y?  Who would then pay more taxes?

Questions for Students

1. What is the minimum and maximum tax in the 15 percent tax bracket?

[$0 is the minimum (on nontaxable income), and$4,867.50 (calculated by 32,450×0.15) is the maximum.]

2. What is the maximum tax in the 28 percent tax bracket?

[78,400-32,450 = 45,950. 45,9500×0.28 = 12,866. Add on the maximum tax from the 15 percent tax bracket ($4,867.50), and the maximum tax in the 28 percent tax bracket is:$12,866+\$4867.50 = 17,733.50.]

3. How much do the actual tax rates vary for the bubble bracket?

[They vary from about 19.27% to 25.83%.]

Teacher Reflection

• How could you differentiate this lesson for struggling learners?
• What did students struggle with the most?
• How could you modify this lesson so that students can better understand taxes?

### Learning Objectives

Students will:

• Work with composition of functions, slopes, averages, and percents.
• Learn to derive equations based on information given.

### NCTM Standards and Expectations

• Analyze functions of one variable by investigating rates of change, intercepts, zeros, asymptotes, and local and global behavior.

### Common Core State Standards – Practice

• CCSS.Math.Practice.MP6
Attend to precision.
• CCSS.Math.Practice.MP7
Look for and make use of structure.